Repaired HVAC

Despite a lot of great advice to the contrary, I opted to have the heat exchanger replaced this week on the gas pack (HVAC) unit on my new house instead of getting a whole new HVAC system.

A couple things really made this decision for me:

the AC side of the gas pack (I was told by the experts) is in amazingly great shape.
I am trying to conserve cash at this point in time.
I had a technician come out and tell me that I should get a new system with the whole sales pitch. I asked him to show my why - he pointed out a couple pieces of rusting sheeting metal that held a sensor at one end of the unit and said he didn't know if he got get that anymore; if it broke, I would need a new unit. After questioning him further - he admitted we could just make the part by shaping a piece of sheet metal if need be in the future.
I kept thinking about my capital investment analysis class back in graduate school and while I never formally put the numbers together I recognized I only needed to keep this unit less than 6 more years to get a good payback on the repair and I know these units can last 20+ years. One of these days I'll have to crunch the numbers and see if this was a good decision.
I just put a completely new system on my other property a few years ago and I think it makes sense to spread out the replacement schedule for future cash management.

In the end it was $2,001.01 to replace the heat exchanger on my 12yr old Carrier gas pack. The technician cleaned the AC side of the gas pack for no charge after I asked him how I could clean it myself.

Now I can focus on rebuilding my cash position.

Related in General:

Black Friday Shopping Highlights (Nov 27, 2011) I have little interest in going out and standing in long lines to pick up a few deals on Black Friday. However we did pick up a few deals over the weekend mostly online: $159 GE Front Loading Washer @...

Roomba Accessory Upgrades (Jul 05, 2011) Well my Roomba finally succumbed to a common issue with the cleaning head module (CHM) that plagues many of these devices. We've been using the Roomba for over 2 years now and have been generally pleased with our investment. See...

A Simple Way To Re-Invigorate Yourself at Your Job (Jun 01, 2011) Lately I have been feeling a bit run down at work. Some things haven't gone my way in the past several months and I've been in the doldrums about my position in general. Lets just say my feet have been...

Comments (2)

Good Luck, hopefully it works out. For as much as I advocated a full replacement of the system I would probably have done the same as you. When you're in a cash strapped situation there isn't too much you can do.

Posted by Matt | September 25, 2006 5:45 PM

Nice! Way to pressure the guy after he told you he might not be able to find a piece of sheet metal bent in a certain direction.

I'm up against the same dilemma with my wifes car. It's old, and we're having to fix or replace some hefty components every once in a while, but it sure beats shelling out the cash for a new one.

-Grant
TheCornerOfficeBlog.com

Posted by Grant | September 25, 2006 8:25 PM